Many shippers evaluating a Digital Freight Matching platform debate whether to conduct transparent freight auctions where prospective bidders see the current low bid before placing their own bid.
At the same time, some carriers express reluctance at participating in transparent freight auctions for fear of driving down freight rates.
In this second in a series of “Best Practices for Optimizing Your Digital Freight Matching (DFM) Platform,” we examine bidder behavior patterns and consider how both shippers and carriers can maximize efficiency by understanding these patterns.
When participating in a transparent bidding process, many carriers incorrectly conclude that the lowest price always wins.
It is true that in this era of tight capacity and rising freight rates, transportation decision-makers face pressure to save money when possible to mitigate the impact of rising rates on their companies’ bottom lines.
We find that shippers award upwards of 80% of loads to the lowest bidder. The second-lowest bidder wins 14% of loads and 4% of loads go to the third-lowest bidder.
Factors that we have found offset the lowest price include carrier ‘quality’, the convenience of award aggregation, and consideration of alternative suppliers.
In only 13% of cases, the lowest bid arrived first. In more than five times as many cases (66%), the lowest bid arrived last. In transparent bidding on loads with no ‘maximum bid’ or ‘I’LL TAKE IT’ price set for the load, bidders typically start the bidding high and subsequent bidders home in the current market price.
Among awarded loads that received three or more bids, shippers awarded 9% to the third to last bidder, 19% to the second to the last bidder, and 57% to the last bidder.
Bid sequence appears to matter even among low bids. We observe that a load has a 41% likelihood of being awarded when the low bid is the first bid. That likelihood nearly doubles to 77% when the low bid is the last bid.
Simply put, we highly recommend that shippers conduct transparent freight auctions rather than obscuring the current low bid from prospective bidders.
In 87% of cases, the lowest bid arrives after the first bid, meaning that most bidders review the first bid and decide to place a lower bid.
To not disadvantage first bidders, we enable all bidders to edit their bid should they wish to “sharpen their pencil” in response to subsequent bids.
Further, since the first bid is seldom the lowest bid, we advise shippers against awarding a load after receiving a single bid but instead allowing enough posting lead time to produce multiple bids.
Bidders also benefit from transparent freight auctions. First, by showing prospective bidders the current low bid, we save bidders time by enabling them to forgo bidding on loads for which they cannot be price competitive.
Second, by showing bidders the auction expiration deadline in combination with the current low bid, we enable bidders who can be price competitive to submit their bid near the auction’s conclusion.
To bidders who greatly desire to secure a particular load, we recommend submitting the low bid late in the auction, resulting in a nearly four-in-five chance of winning.
To learn more about how PostBidShip’s Digital Freight Matching Platform can help you optimize your spot market freight bidding, please contact us.
About PostBidShip
PostBidShip is a neutral digital freight matching (DFM) platform that replaces outdated workflows with quick, cost-effective, and efficient matching of loads to transportation capacity in real-time, using near-time data analytics, market indices modeling and real-time digital collaboration, benefiting both parties through an optimal mix of cost, performance, convenience and asset utilization.
Related Optimizing Digital Freight Matching Platforms: Posting Lead Times to Maximize Spot Market Response
Related Papers
Why CARRIERS Need a Digital Freight Matching Platform
This white paper explains why business-to-business carriers today benefit from access to a neutral digital freight matching platform to best use their available capacity, resources, and equipment. Download Now!
Why SHIPPERS Need a Digital Freight Matching Platform
This white paper explains why business-to-business shippers today benefit from access to a neutral digital freight matching platform to best use their available freight spend and human capital resources on behalf of their company. Download Now!
More PostBidShip Resources