Transportation News

Transportation Route Planning: Are You Leaving Money on the Table?

An important role of a TMS is defining and calculating cost savings.

Route planning - how to deliver freight for the lowest cost, and in a way that meets the constraints and requirements of the order - has been at the core of transportation management systems (TMS) since I wrote the first one in the late 1980s.

In fact, I began developing algorithms to solve the routing problem as early as 1984 or 1985.

While the algorithms improved dramatically since then, the basic concept of route planning did not: Logistics professionals still have to create a large set of transportation options that span all of the possible ways to move the freight, plus allow providers wide latitude in how they structure the options.

The algorithm considers all of these possible options, models them as accurately as possible, accounts for constraints (if known in advance) and charges appropriately.

From Simplicity to Flexibility

As the transportation industry grows more complex and more factors weigh on the true cost of a shipment, the need for more sophisticated automation is increasing. In the past, software created simplicity in the routing process so that a manual route planner or a weak TMS could handle it. And that left a lot of money on the table.

But today, with more complexity and more powerful software than ever before, the need for simplicity is replaced with the need for a system to manage pricing flexibility that reflects actual costs. This allows logistics professionals to get very creative about route planning—and I think this is one of the most exciting areas of the transportation industry.

How Poor Routing Planning Loses Money

Simplified routing planning isn’t doing your organization any favors, especially when modern TMS systems and algorithms can manage the complexity and lower your freight spend.

Are you leaving money on the table with your TMS? Let me provide some possibilities.

Most companies ask their less-than-truckload (LTL) providers to bid off one tariff. Then they compare discounts and other ancillary issues to select carriers for lanes. This enables simple routing in which a shipment of the right size going in a certain lane gets a pre-determined LTL carrier assigned.

A newer generation TMS, however, allows each carrier to bid very specifically, including off any tariff in which they can be most aggressive. The carriers can set up rates that reflect their costs—as opposed to general assumptions—which allows them to be more aggressive in pricing. Then the TMS can look at each option, figure out if it’s feasible, determine the cost and select the lowest price option.

Very few companies actually use pool distribution. Those that do tend to set up one point per region, and assign freight within a size range and geographic range to that pool point.

A better approach is to allow several possible pool points in every area and have the routing algorithm select which one(s) is appropriate for a load based on the mix of freight. Furthermore, the determination of whether a shipment gets delivered as a stop in transit or on a pool point should not be based on shipment size; it should be based on cost.

Depending on the route, a smaller shipment in route is often cheaper to ship as a stop in transit, while a larger shipment out of route is usually cheaper to deliver out of the pool point. When pool distribution is done right, organizations can save significant costs because of it.

The point is that you need to think in terms of flexibility and adding options with your TMS—not the simplification and elimination that are traditionally used when routing freight manually or with a weak TMS.

Defining and Calculating Cost Savings

In addition to route planning, another important role of a TMS is defining and calculating cost savings. Today’s TMS systems are making huge strides in savings calculations compared to earlier generations of the software.

Many companies think about cost purely from a decision-making perspective: For every transportation option, there is a savings of one versus another.

But there are more accurate ways of addressing cost that only third-generation TMSs—ones designed in the last several years—can address. Within them exist concepts around base costs and savings of suggested routing versus the base cost.

There is also a concept of routes (groups of orders traveling together) and looking at savings over the entire route. Both of these are big, complex and nuanced innovations that are enabling third-generation users to achieve much greater savings than second-generation users.

And with the concept of savings versus historical approaches, you can better understand what you would spend moving freight with your old routing approach versus what you actually spent.

Lastly, third-generation TMS products approach savings in terms of marginal costs—not allocated costs—which can generate significantly greater savings. Let’s say you have a load going from Memphis to the Northeast and making a pool stop in the Lancaster, Pennsylvania area. Maybe it’s a great load that still has a little room in it.

You also have a shipment going to Augusta, Maine. This could fit on the truck and then the cost of the pool shipment from Lancaster to Augusta would be lower than the cost of Memphis to Augusta. However, when you add the allocated cost of the truckload, the pool shipment is more expensive.

This is faulty, second-generation logic. The allocated cost of the truckload is meaningless! That load is already going and so the Augusta shipment rides for free. The optimization, therefore, needs to look at the marginal cost of adding the shipment to the load and not simplistic allocations.

Get Out of the Dark Ages of Routing

Today’s third-generation TMS optimization engine is far more powerful, flexible and sophisticated than prior generation products—and it’s completely changing the approach to route planning. Now, you can be more creative and drive significant cuts in freight spend compared with older, more rigid TMS products.

Related White Papers

Download the Paper

What’s Changed with A Modern TMS?
The Transportation World has Changed Dramatically, are you changing with it? Download Now!


Download the Paper

3PL Enhances Competitive Advantage and Strengthens Non-Asset Line of Business with Tier 1 TMS
Unlike other offerings that were built decades ago, 3Gtms technology addresses today’s market needs and complexities. Download Now!


Download the Paper

TMS Solution Increases Automation and Streamlines Operations
Manufacturer Streamlines Processes and Enables New Business Initiatives with Robust, Flexible Multi-Mode TMS. Download Now!


Download the Paper

Multi-Mode, Tier 1 TMS Enables Greater Automation
A Tier 1 TMS, 3G-TM increases productivity by improving shipment efficiency and communications; reducing freight cost; increasing shipment visibility; and providing greater financial transparency. Download Now!


Article Topics
Best Practices   Transportation   Transportation Management   Less-than-Truckload   Transportation Management   Truckload   All topics


Comments
Be the first to post a comment.
You must be logged in to post a comment. Login.

 
Latest Transportation News
XPO Logistics Named One of the World’s Most Admired Companies by Forbes Magazine
2018 is the first year XPO Logistics, a global provider of transport and logistics solutions and which operates as a highly integrated network of people, technology, and physical assets in 32 countries,…

Retailers Versus The Amazon Effect
Amazon has set the standard for customer service and today every consumer expects every retailer to have the same service capabilities from their e-commerce business including an integrated transport management…

Transportation Predictions That Will Shake-Up the Supply Chain Industry In 2018
Dan Clark, Founder and President of Kuebix, gives his annual vision of what he sees happening in the transportation and supply chain industry including; tax reforms, decreased capacity, higher rates, and…

Home Depot Considers Buying $9 Billion XPO Logistics So Amazon Doesn’t
If Home Depot were to make an offer, one main impetus would be to keep XPO out of the hands of Amazon, which the home improvement retailer believes has also considered buying the logistics company, according…


 

24|7 Pro Team

The 24|7 Team is your direct pipeline to solutions for your business challenges. It's your opportunity to have supply chain and logistics experts look at your specific challenges and needs, and give you free, no-obligation advice, solutions, and information.

The 24|7 Team will simplify the task of creating a database of likely partners, building your knowledge base, and preparing your Request for Proposal list.

1
  Choose a topic for your RFP

Transportation RFP/RFI

The Transportation RFP is your direct pipeline to solutions for your transportation challenges. It's your opportunity to have logistics experts look at your specific transportation challenges and needs, and give you free, no-obligation advice, solutions, and information specific to your request.

Choosing the perfect software or system can be an indomitable challenge. Using this transportation/TMS RFP will simplify the task of creating a database of likely partners, building your knowledge base, and preparing your Request for Proposal list.

Warehouse/DC Management RFP/RFI

The Warehouse Management Systems (WMS) RFP is your direct pipeline to solutions for your WMS challenges. It's your opportunity to have logistics experts look at your specific WMS challenges and needs, and give you free, no-obligation advice, solutions, and information specific to your request.

Choosing the perfect WMS solution can be an indomitable challenge. Using this WMS RFP will simplify the task of creating a database of likely partners, building your knowledge base, and preparing your WMS Request for Proposal list.

Supply Chain RFP/RFI

The Supply Chain RFP is your opportunity to have logistics experts look at your specific challenges and needs, and receive free, no-obligation advice, solutions, and information. It simplifies finding a pool of likely partners, building your knowledge base, and preparing your Request for Proposal list. The companies in the Logistics Planner have agreed to respond to your request for in-depth information and follow-up, and your request is totally confidential.

Software/Technology RFP/RFI

The Software/Technology is your direct pipeline to solutions for your logistics information technology challenges. It's your opportunity to have logistics experts look at your specific technology challenges and needs, and give you free, no-obligation advice, solutions, and information specific to your request. Whether it's WMS, TMS, Mobile or Cloud, our pros can help.

The companies listed below have agreed to respond to your request for in-depth information and follow-up. Your request is totally confidential.

Executive Education RFI

The Logistics and Supply Chain Education RFI can help you identify the schools, coursework, continuing education, distance learning and certification opportunities available from leading logistics educational institutions.

Upgrade and improve your logistics and supply chain skillsets. Whatever route you choose—advanced degree, executive education, certification or distance learning—the time and money you invest in your education today can pay off in continued career success tomorrow. Contact leading universities and professional institutions for the information you need to prepare for the future.

Third Party Logistics RFP/RFI

This 3PL Request for Proposal (RFP)/Request for Information (RFI) can help you find the 3PL and 4PL providers that can meet your specific 3PL service challenges and needs. The 3PL companies below will provide free, no-obligation third-party logistics advice, solutions, and information.

Ask your 3PL questions, you'll get answers. Simply complete the information, and detail your 3PL challenges. Then, check off the third-party logistics companies that you want to review your request.

1. Choose an RFI topic.
2. Enter your contact information and challenge.
3. Select companies and optional categories.
4. Submit.


2

Your Information



Your Challenge, Problem or Request *

3

Select Transportation Companies

  • Select All

  • 3Gtms
  • BluJay Solutions
  • CSX Trans. Intermodal
  • Kuebix
  • Landstar
  • Legacy Supply Chain Svs.
  • One Network
  • Pitt Ohio
  • Purolator
  • Quintiq
  • SEKO Logistics
  • SMC3


Select Relevent Categories

  • Air Freight
  • Intermodal
  • Motor Freight
  • Ocean Freight
  • Rail Freight
  • TMS

Select Warehouse/DC Management Companies

  • Select All

  • 3PL Central
  • Apex Supply Chain Tech.
  • Honeywell Intelligrated
  • Kuebix
  • Legacy Supply Chain Svs.
  • Swisslog
  • Westfalia Technologies
  • Zebra Technologies


Select Relevent Categories

  • Auto ID & Data Capture
  • Automation
  • Conveyors & Sortation
  • Lift Trucks
  • Packaging & Labeling
  • Pallets & Containers
  • Shelving & Racking
  • WMS

Select Supply Chain Companies

  • Select All

  • 3Gtms
  • 3PL Central
  • Amber Road
  • Apex Supply Chain Tech.
  • APICS
  • BluJay Solutions
  • CSX Trans. Intermodal
  • Frontier Business
  • Kuebix
  • Legacy Supply Chain Svs.
  • Logility
  • One Network
  • Purolator
  • Quintiq
  • SMC3
  • Synchrono
  • TAKE Supply Chain
  • Westfalia Technologies
  • Zebra Technologies


Select Relevent Categories

  • Global Trade
  • Inventory Management
  • Risk Management
  • Sustainability

Select Software/Technology Companies

  • Select All

  • 3GTMS
  • 3PL Central
  • Apex Supply Chain Tech.
  • BluJay Solutions
  • Honeywell Intelligrated
  • Frontier Business
  • Kuebix
  • Logility
  • One Network
  • Quintiq
  • SMC3
  • Swisslog Logistics
  • Synchrono
  • TAKE Supply Chain
  • Zebra Technologies


Select Relevent Categories

  • ERP
  • Sales & Operations
  • Sourcing/Procurement
  • Optimization
  • Transportation Mgmt
  • Warehouse Mgmt

Select Executive Education Choices

  • Select All

  • Graduate Courses
  • Online/Distance
  • Executive Education
  • Certifications
  • Undergraduate
  • Seminars
  • Associations
  • Conferences
  • Tradeshows


Select Third Party Logistics Companies

  • Select All

  • 3PL Central
  • Landstar
  • Legacy Supply Chain Svs.
  • Purolator
  • SEKO Logistics
  • Westfalia Technologies


4
 

24|7 Company Profiles